Retirements Open Doors for Two
Pitcher Boots Thompson and Catcher Steve Wright have hung up the cleats, inciting a battle for the two vacated roster spots
For Tommy Blake and Bruno Bow, news of pitcher Big Boots Thompson's sudden retirement was not bad news at all; for these two pitchers who were on the outside looking in, it meant a shot at solidifying a spot within the Aviators organization. But do either of these two pitchers have what it takes to make it in the big leagues?
Blake started last season in AA Greenville, where he was 3-1, 1.72 in 5 starts before being promoted to AAA Raleigh. Just two starts into his AAA career, Boots was placed on the DL, giving Blake what he thought was a temporary assignment to the Majors. Blake entered the rotation but struggled, and was moved to the bullpen to provide depth as other pitchers tried to fill in the whole in the rotation. On the whole, his major league line was not a disaster; 3-5-0, 4.66 in 24 appearances (including 9 starts) and a WHIP of 1.64. The 31-year-old throws 6 different pitches, with the Cutter being his best (7). He is smart and REALLY wants to win, and has a work ethic worthy of the Aviator way. Stamina is an issue, but he is probably better suited for the rotation than his competition, Bruno Bow.
Bow is a 25-year-old hailing from New Canaan, CT, who began last season in rookie ball. After going 8-2 in 14 starts for the Delray Beach Grasshoppers, he was called up to the single-A Outer Banks Privateers, where he struggled to a 4-5 mark with a 5.89 ERA in 11 starts. With pitching thin in the Aviators system, Bow earned a September call-up, and pitched 5 innings over the course of 3 appearances, allowing 7 ER on 10 hits, walking 2 and fanning 2. Clearly not ready for the show as of September, it's going to take a hell of a Spring campaign to get Bow onto the 25-man roster for opening day.
That, or dare I say, another injury.
FOUR players are dueling it out for 2 roster spots behind the plate. Sid Matthews, Mario Melendez, Gravel Rhodes, and Sandro Rodriguez are all very similar according to scouting reports, and narrowing the field down to 2 will be a tall order this Spring.
The most experienced of these players is 32-year-old Sid Mathews, who logged 165 at bats for NC in 90 games last season (.206-2-15). Once a pretty good defensive backstop, Mathews has seen his abilities deteriorate rapidly over the past 2 years, and now he's rated just a 1 at catcher (3 arm) by scouts. Since his stick isn't that great, that means he's good at, well, nothing really. Check that; he can draw a walk. Career line: .201-12-60 in 608 ABs.
Next up we have a pair of first round draft picks. Mario Melendez (10th overall pick in 2014) and Gravel Rhodes (13th overall pick in 2013). Let's start with Melendez, who has some big league experience. The 24-year-old appeared in 39 games last season, posting a .181-4-5 mark in 94 at bats. Prior to his call-up, he hit .284-16-65 in 95 games for the Raleigh Explorers. Scouts tend to like Melendez, predicting him to be a good power-hitter with a great presence in the locker room and a leader on the field. However, he doesn't appear to have a high ceiling defensively, which could be a problem.
Rhodes is a tad younger than Melendez at 23 years of age, and is a good defensive catcher with a great arm. He does not quite possess Melendez's knack for the long ball, but has slightly better gap power and is much tougher to fan. Rhodes was successful in AAA Raleigh, batting .313 with 6 HR and 24 RBI while fanning only 22 times in 115 ABs last season. He also hit .329 in 252 bats in single-A OBX and .151 in 52 AA at bats.
The fourth and final candidate, Sandro Rodriguez, is a 25-year-old without the pedigree of Rhodes or Melendez. He spent 2017 in Greenville (.278-10-69 in 103 games) and Raleigh (.264-2-10 in 22 games). So, while he's young, lacks experience, and lacks potential, he might be the best player offensively AND defensively when looking solely at current scouting reports. If Gravel and Mario fail to perform well this Spring, Sandro could be the stopgap even though he's not really a major league player long term.